Tuesday, March 30, 2010

Maus: A Survivor's Tale by Art Spiegelman

AUTHOR INFORMATION
Art Spiegelman was born in Stockholm, Sweden in 1948. He immigrated to the United States with his family at a young age. Although his parents wanted him to be a dentist, Spiegelman went to 
college for art and philosophy. Spiegelman has created many cartoons but Maus is what launched his successful career. Maus is based on his parents' experiences surviving the concentration camps under Hitler's Nazi Party. Originally, the project started as a small comic strip but Spiegelman eventually turned it into a full graphic novel. The first book, Maus: A Survivor's Tale (1986) earned great respect and was followed in 1991 by the second installment, Maus II: From Mauschwitz to the Catskills. Art Spiegelman won the Pulitzer Prize in 1992 for his work.
  • Interview with Art Spiegelman
  • The Man Behind Maus
  • In the video below, Art Spiegelman talks about how he creates cartoons, the meaning of cartooning to him, and his views on artwork in society. Portions of the interview may not be suitable for younger audiences. 

CLASSROOM APPLICATION
  • Maus: A Survivor's Tale is very suitable for a variety of learners and classrooms at different levels. I think the best place to introduce the book would be in a secondary level classroom. Although high school students may have a better grasp on the content of the book and thereby a more mature analysis, the basic story and format is suitable for middle school students.
  • Art Spiegelman's graphic novels could be used in English, social studies, psychology, sociology, and art classes. Likewise, the book could be used to address a variety of different topics that pertain to specific elements of different content areas. (Including, but not limited to: analyzing social justice issues, analyzing and determining literature elements, practicing art techniques, and sequencing/comprehending historical facts.)


USING MAUS: A SURVIVOR'S TALE IN THE CLASSROOM
  • Despite the class content area, I think it is important that the teacher introduces the Holocaust and gives some historical background about the events surrounding the Holocaust. It may be valuable to discuss the term genocide with students and compare the Holocaust to the modern day crisis in Darfur using the common term. This is a way of incorporating current events and making the events of the Holocaust more relevant and meaningful for students today.
  • When teaching Maus: A Survivor's Tale, especially in an English classroom, it is important to discuss that it is an allegory


EXTENSION ACTIVITIES FOR THE CLASSROOM
  • After reading the graphic novel, have students create their own cartoons using one of the online resources below. Of course, if the Internet is not available, students could create their own cartoons by hand.
  • Students can be broken up to discuss the various elements, themes, and logistics of the text. The link below provides sample questions for different stations. These questions are generic and could be used with any text.
  • Students can participate in literature circles and an online WebQuest after reading the text. The link below contains a teacher created lesson for each activity. It could modified easily to fit various educators' needs.
  • Have students read the graphic novel in class and complete various synthesis and analysis activities. Students could even research the author and his genre further. As a final step, allow the students to edit the Wikipedia page abouMaus by filling in missing information, providing reflections, or giving citations for information that has not be verified.
  • Have students complete the graphic novel and then read reviews of the text. Once the students have looked at various reviews, have them write their own review about the graphic novel supporting their answer with specific details.
  • Before, during, or after reading parts of the graphic novel, have students fill in what they think the text should be on any given section or page. It is useful for students to predict what the dialogue should be using the story line and pictures. I have made an example below of a section I would pass out to students. I have blocked out the author's text so that students can create their own. Some websites have sections of the book scanned so it is easy to cover the author's text using a text box or white square in Word or PowerPoint.



TEACHER RESOURCES FOR MAUS


RELEVANT LINKS

  1. Maus: A Suvivor's Tale deals with a very difficult topic and an extremely emotional situation. Do you think making it into a graphic novel was an effective way to portray the story? Do you think that making a story of the Holocaust into a graphic novel kept it respectable?
  2. How does the relationship between Vladek and Artie change or develop during the story? How does the author represent Vladek?
  3. Multiple conflicts emerge throughout the graphic novel and almost all of them come back to have some effect on Artie. What is one of these conflicts? Why is it pertinent to the story? Who does it effect? Why does it effect those people? How does it come back or directly effect Artie?
  4. Spiegelman transports the reader into a land of mice, cats, and other animals in conflict. How does he make sure the reader doesn't get lost in a world of fantasy? What elements in the book connect the reader to the real events of the Holocaust?
  5. In a sense, a graphic novel is an extended comic strip and could be viewed as unworthy of being in classroom. Do you agree that Maus: A Survivor's Tale should be used in a classroom setting? Why? Why not? What makes it different from a typical comic? Are there elements that make it the same as a typical comic?

11 comments:

  1. A have a response to a couple of your discussion questions. In number four you talk about the characters being portrayed as animals presents the risk that students may be stuck in fantasy. But what about talking about what the animals represent? Jews are mice, police are pigs, etc. What's the significance of it?

    And in number five, of course it should be used in the classroom! But I think the question is a great one. A teacher needs to be sure of the motives behind the choice when teaching a book. What if an administrator doesn't agree with using this book? A teacher needs to think about this, and have reasons to back up his or her decisions.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really like all of the instructional suggestions you offer. It was very interesting for me to read this book after just finishing a unit on Anne Frank with 8th graders. I kept wondering how it could be incorporated into that unit. I particularly thought of a few boys in my class who love to draw more than they love to read or write. Maus could have acted as an awesome model for them for a graphic variation of the final project which centered on a personal response to genocide. I'm really gald to have this book in my repertoire now!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks, Michael. I really love the links to the interviews and the video that you included in your post. Particularly with a memoir with content that is fraught with emotional paradox, it's important to envision (and if possible) hear the human voice of the author alongside the text. This is not to say that students cannot create their own meaning (and I love the instructional activity of filling in blank cartoon bubbles on frames from the book), but it seems very important to place the work in its particular context as play between present and past, son and father, personal and public history, etc. And Speigelman has really eloquent thoughts on all of these issues...

    Thanks, again!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I haven't read this text but from what I've heard from multiple sources, I think it would be a great addition to a text set around the Holocaust. From my own experience with different texts about the Holocaust, I have yet to see anything like this. I think this would definitely be engaging for those students who are turned off by the traditional texts we typically use to teach this topic.

    I think it's great that you also show just how easily this text can be used across the content areas! Great job!

    ReplyDelete
  5. At first I was reluctant to embrace the graphic novel, after reading Maus I want to more. Graphic novels would really resonant with my current students. The visual support along with non overwhelming text would be embraced among the class. At first, the students might need time to get used to reading graphic novels- and I think they would need scaffolding to see the value in this genre. But, with the appropriate implementation in the classroom graphic novels could serve to enhance lessons.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Did you find that your ideas about graphic novels changed as you went through this activity and process? I have come to enjoy graphic novels. My first experience was with "Bone out of Boneville". I appreciate the skill set it takes to draw the storyline as well as write the storyline.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I think your applications of Maus I across disciplines is great. Too often students question "whats the point?" or "why do we have to learn this?", and when we are able to tie themes into all different subject areas (with which the Holocaust certainley can be done) the importance seems magnified.

    Thank you for posting the links regarding
    how to use graphic novels. As much as teachers are meant to be the authority in the classroom, graphic novels can be new and challenging for many educators, it certainley would be for me. I can only imagine that if we as "good readers" are having some trouble with the genre, or at least needing to take a bit more time to really focus on the text, that our students may be having difficulties as well. In our class discussions people spoke about using other shorter graphic novels or picture books as a seg-way into this text. I did a bit of research and there are some great picture books which would aid with the visual aspect of Maus (imagrey, visual expression, etc.) Some to consider are: "The Poisonous Mushroom"- this text is written from the Nazi perspective but the pictures really show how images can be used to evoke emotion and fear. "I never saw another butterfly" which is a collection of poems and artwork created by children in the Terezin camp. "One Candle" by Eve Bunting which tells the story of a grandmothers experience as a child during the Holocaust. None of these texts are explicitly the same as Maus I, but all deal with the same content and may be an option to begin graphic novels with.

    ReplyDelete
  8. The cool thing about Maus is the ability to use it across the curriculum! I read this on my own a while back and I think that with the ideas you have shared, this book could be taken as seriously as the Anne Frank text...

    ReplyDelete
  9. I love all of the extension activities you listed. It's great to see such a range of activities that can be applied to the text.
    In response to #5, I was a skeptic about graphic novels, but after reading Maus, I changed my tune. It is more insightful than I thought it would be and I really appreciated what it had to deliver. I think that especially for struggling readers, graphic novels would make a great addition to the classroom.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Having read this I thought it was really enlightening. I appreciate you finding the time and energy to put this content together. I once again find myself personally spending way too much time both reading and posting comments. But so what, it was still worth it! tikus

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thanks for the idea about blanking out parts of the text and anticipating what it might say based on the picture. Kind of reminds me of the New Yorker cartoon contests, which might be an intriguing way to start examining how text and pictures interact, come to think of it.

    ReplyDelete